Digital Identity is Creepy

Digital identity is more than just a tool; it's a reflection of who we are. The pervasive and often opaque ways in which our identities are managed can feel invasive and, frankly, creepy.

September 21, 2024

Introduction

In today’s digital age, our identities are increasingly being captured, stored, and monetised by a multitude of digital identity vendors. This phenomenon, while offering convenience and security, also introduces unsettling implications for privacy and personal autonomy. Digital identity is more than just a tool; it’s a reflection of who we are. The pervasive and often opaque ways in which our identities are managed can feel invasive and, frankly, creepy.

The Commodification of Identity

Digital identity vendors turn our personal data into a commodity. Companies collect extensive data about our habits, preferences, and behaviours, creating detailed profiles that are bought and sold for profit. This practice reduces our identities to mere data points, stripping away the human element and exposing us to potential exploitation.

The Illusion of Security

Many digital identity solutions promise security through sophisticated verification processes. However, the centralisation of sensitive personal information in massive databases creates attractive targets for hackers. Breaches can have devastating consequences, exposing millions to identity theft and financial fraud. This false sense of security often lulls consumers into complacency, making them unaware of the real risks involved.

Privacy Erosion

The constant surveillance and data collection by digital identity vendors erode our privacy. Every click, purchase, and interaction is tracked and analysed. This omnipresent scrutiny leads to a sense of being perpetually watched, which can be deeply unsettling. Our private lives become transparent to corporations, leaving us vulnerable to manipulation and control.

Ethical Concerns

The ethical implications of digital identity management are profound. Who owns our digital identity? Should companies have the right to profit from our personal data? These questions highlight the moral dilemmas at the heart of the digital identity industry. When identity becomes a product, we lose control over how we are represented and perceived.

That has a human cost. Individuals can feel dehumanised when their identity is reduced to a series of algorithms and data points. This depersonalisation can lead to a loss of agency and autonomy, affecting our mental and emotional well-being.

What next?

To address these concerns, we must explore alternatives that prioritise user control and privacy. The current state of digital identity management is fraught with issues that compromise our privacy, security, and autonomy. Consumers and citizens need better practices and more ethical approaches to digital identity. By advocating for solutions that respect our individuality and protect our personal data, we can mitigate the creepy aspects of digital identity and reclaim control over our digital selves.

Secure in Name Only
Exploring how metaphors like “vaults,” “keys,” and “wallets” shape our sense of safety—and the risks that confidence creates.
Are we getting closer to a true identity layer?
Initiatives like W3C Decentralized Identifiers (DIDs) and Verifiable Credentials (VCs) are moving us toward an identity layer
The internet was built for machines not people
The internet has no built-in identity layer — it only knows devices and keys, not people. Everything we call “online identity” is an application-level patch, and that’s why the web’s trust and security problems are so persistent.‍